MikroTik - Wireless | Batna24.com

MikroTik - Wireless

microtik-1 Kliknij aby powiększyć!
A very popular belief is that MikroTik as a WiFi router is not the best choice for office or business applications, due to much worse wireless performance compared to devices from other manufacturers.

I do not agree with this statement, because it is not true. In the entry below I will try to objectively present the reasons for such an opinion and show you how you can squeeze out the results from MikroTik devices comparable to other wireless devices of the same class. I base my opinion on the tests carried out on several dozen models of wireless routers during the last 6 months of the tests. The tests were conducted in identical conditions, in the same place so as to obtain materials for comparison with as few variable factors as possible. Most of the test results were published on the BATNA24 website in the section Device tests, and their summary can be found in a series of entries "Great Access Point Test 2020".

microtik2 Kliknij aby powiększyć!

Let's start with a theory...

Most currently sold WiFi routers MikroTik are based on the IPQ-4018/4019 platform providing only the AC1200 standard in the MIMO 2x2, i.e. at a frequency of 5GHz they can work at a maximum speed of 867Mbit/s (PHY) using two receiving and transmitting tracks simultaneously. Despite the high value of maximum physical speed (PHY) 867Mbit/s, much lower speed is available in practice. This is due to the overhead of protocols, preventing collision between packets and in practice it comes down to the fact that having a negotiated wireless speed of 867Mbit/s in ideal conditions we can get 520Mbit/s up to a maximum of 610Mbit/s.

The ideal conditions are:

  • low distance up to 2-4m

  • no interference (ambient noise below -110dBm)

  • no obstacles between transmitter and receiver antennas

  • negotiation of SGi

  • Low number of wireless devices connected to the transmitter In a great simplification, it should be assumed that the surcharge of wireless protocol, the time needed to avoid collisions between the receivers causes a loss of about 40% of speed. So if the device is negotiating 1300Mbit/s (PHY), we can really get within 800Mbit/s. In some situations the results can be a little better or worse.

    With an example of a simplified calculation:

  • table of figures Kliknij aby powiększyć!
    A section of the full wireless speed table (PHY data rate) is presented in the table below.
    table2 Kliknij aby powiększyć!

    It's time for the WiFi router specifications...

    I haven't met anyone yet to give a reliable account of the results achieved by WiFi routers produced by MikroTik compared to those produced by Ubiquiti Networks. It always says "if you want to have good WiFi, don't buy MikroTik but buy Ubiquiti devices". I won't deny here that when looking at the whole thing, most Ubiquiti devices get better radio parameters than MikroTik. This is only due to the following factors:

    1. Devices of different speed standards are compared, most of the MikroTik devices only operate in the 5GHz band at 867Mbit/s, while almost all Ubiquiti devices operate at speeds in this band 1300Mbit/s or 1733Mbit/s. As you can see on the table above, the difference in real bandwidth is significant between these devices. Below is a table with parameters of sample routers.

    2. MikroTik version of RouterOS 6.46/6.47 does not support all functionalities from Wave2 standards, which is fully implemented in Ubiquiti.

    3. MikroTik devices usually work simultaneously as a firewall and/or NAT, which functionality reduces the performance of its WiFi, while Ubiquiti devices are separated in this functionality.

    4. Most Ubiquiti devices are designed to be mounted on a wall or suspended from the ceiling. This way of mounting ensures that the wireless signal can spread freely without interference. On the other hand, MikroTik devices are mostly designed to be placed on a desk/shelf where there are many objects suppressing the signal and generating interference with reflections.

    5. Platform performance (CPU, radio chip) is not comparable, which is reflected in the product price.

    The models and their radio parameters.

    Manufacturer and model of device Number of radio tracks Radio speed (PHY data rate) Expected actual speed (TCP/UDP) (*
    Ubiquiti Networks AmpliFi HD Mesh Router 3 1300Mbit/s 750-845Mbit/s
    Ubiquiti Networks UniFi AC PRO
    Ubiquiti Networks UniFi AC Lite 2 867Mbit/s450-610Mbit/s
    Ubiquiti Networks UniFi Nano HD 4 1733Mbit/s1000-1100Mbit/s
    MikroTik hAP ac lite 1 433Mbit/s250-280Mbit/s
    MikroTik cAP ac 2 867Mbit/s450-610Mbit/s
    MikroTik wAP ac
    MikroTik hAP ac2
    MikroTik hAP ac3
    MikroTik Chateau
    MikroTik Audience(** 4 1733Mbit/s1000-1100Mbit/s
    Xiaomi AIoT AC2350 4 1733Mbit/s1000-1100Mbit/s
    TP-Link Archer C6 2 867Mbit/s450-610Mbit/s
    TP-Link Archer C1200 2 867Mbit/s450-610Mbit/s
    Totolink A7000R 4 1733Mbit/s1000-1100Mbit/s
    Totolink A3002RU 2 867Mbit/s450-610Mbit/s
    Totolink A800R 2 867Mbit/s450-610Mbit/s

    *) - The value is a certain simplification of the calculation of subtracting the markup of wireless protocols and other factors influencing the achieved throughput. In fact, it may be lower or higher than local conditions and client devices.

    **) - MicroTik Audience requires RouterOS 7.x, which at this stage is still in the BETA phase and maximum results cannot be expected.

    Oversized wireless settings

    Nearly all manufacturers of SOHO type devices, i.e. devices intended for use in homes and small offices, focus on simplicity of configuration and limit the number of parameters that the user can set to a minimum.

    Another policy is pursued by MikroTik, which wants to give access to as many parameters as possible. This is due to the fact that MikroTik was initially a solution designed exclusively for professionals who know how a particular parameter works independently and how it affects the results as a whole. This cannot be expected from a typical user of home or small office solutions. Changing even a small parameter in the default configuration can cause a drastic drop in wireless network performance. This is due to the fact that MikroTik devices can be set differently than the 802.11n/802.11ac WiFi standard, but this is not a drawback, but only the functionality expected by specialists.

    I will describe below the most common setting error, i.e. incorrectly selected operating range for channels of 40/80/160MHz width.

    With the 802.11n/802.11ac standards, most devices can only work in the default settings of the channel frequency range (start and end frequency). If 802.11ac standard for channel number 106 with 80MHz width defines operation in frequency range 5490-5570MHz, only a transmitter working exactly the same way will allow maximum throughput. If the user of MikroTik devices sets parameters manually:

  • Channel Width: 20/40/80MHz Ceee
  • Frequency 5540MHz

    this will result in a reduction of maximum performance by more than half and even more in practice. The point is that we set this definition that our channel works in the frequency range 55300-5610MHz, and this is inconsistent with the plan of 802.11n/ac. standard channels.

  • microtik3 Kliknij aby powiększyć!
    To eliminate such a problem, MikroTik has introduced the possibility of setting "Width Channel":
  • 20/40MHz XX
  • 20/40/80MHZ XXXX

    Where XX/XXXX was to symbolize that the device itself would select the frequency of the control channel and the rest of the initial and final frequency range. This all works correctly only when we have pure ether from other transmitters. In the case of higher density of transmitters, MikroTik is able to incorrectly select the control channel and the initial and final frequency, which gives us the effect of lowering the total throughput of the transmitter and instead of obtaining speeds >400Mbps we get barely 100-200Mbps.

    The control channel in the recording used by MikroTik is represented by the letter "C" and the 20MHz to 40/80/160MHz expansion channels are represented by the letter "e". Examples of 5540/20-eCee recording means that the 20MHz control channel is set to 5540MHz centre frequency. The initial frequency of the control channel for the 5GHz band is determined by subtracting 10MHz from the centre value of 5540MHz, and the final frequency is determined by adding +10MHz to the centre value, so in this case the control channel is in the 5530-5550MHz range. From this range we subtract from the lower value as many times the value of 20MHz as we have the letters "e" before "C" and add to the higher value as many times the value of 20MHz as we have the letters "e" after "C". In our example from 5530 we subtract 20MHz once, which gives us value 5510MHz, and to 5550 we add twice 20MHz (+40MHz) which gives us value 5590MHz. The obtained values are the initial value of the channel frequency equal to 5510MHz and the final value of the channel frequency equal to 5590MHz (5510MHz-5590MHz).

    For example, MicroTik can do with settings:

  • Channel Width: 20/40/80MHZ XXXX
  • Frequency: auto
  • Frequency Mode: controller-domain
  • Country: etsi or Poland

    set up the channel described: 5520/20-Ceeee, which works in the 5510-5590MHz range and does not hit the 106 channel, so we lose a lot on performance.

  • microtik4 Kliknij aby powiększyć!
    There is only one conclusion, do not rely on the default settings. And in case of poor results of the default configuration, verify on which frequencies your WiFi transmitter works in MikroTik.

    Basing on my experience with testing Ubiquiti, Cambium, Totolink, Aruba, TP-Link devices, I didn't notice that they allow to set different frequency range of the initial and final channel on which they work.

    What can I change so I don't overdo it?

    In fact, there's not much you can do without a thorough knowledge of the function. The best results are always obtained at the same settings. For example in MikroTik hAP ac3 to get 500Mbps performance in TCP/UDP I set:

    1. Band" value to "5GHz-N/AC (bookmark: Wireless)

    2. I don't use a wireless network to transmit an IPTV stream so I turn off the "Multicast Helper" (bookmark: Wireless)

    3. If necessary, I turn on "Advanced" and set "Hw. Retries" to 10 (tab: Advanced)

    4. Make sure you set the correct channel width.

    microtik6 Kliknij aby powiększyć!
    microtik7 Kliknij aby powiększyć!

    Products

    MikroTik hAP ac lite tower | WiFi Router | RB952Ui-5ac2nD-TC, Dual Band, 5x RJ45 100Mb/s
    MIKROTIK
    Product code: RB952UI-5AC2ND-TC (EU)
    sentiment_very_satisfied star_border star_border star_border star_border star_border

    we usually ship in 1 day: 24h

    AVAILABILITY
    35,03 GBP

    with VAT

    we usually ship in 1 day: 24h

    MikroTik cAP ac | Access point | RBcAPGi-5acD2nD, Dual Band, 2x RJ45 1000Mb/s
    MIKROTIK
    Product code: RBCAPGI-5ACD2ND
    sentiment_very_satisfied star_border star_border star_border star_border star_border

    possible availability within 7 days

    AVAILABILITY
    live_help
    50,91 GBP

    with VAT

    possible availability within 7 days

    MikroTik hAP ac2 tower | WiFi Router | RBD52G-5HacD2HnD-TC, Dual Band, 5x RJ45 1000Mb/s, 1x USB
    MIKROTIK
    Product code: RBD52G-5HACD2HND-TC
    sentiment_very_satisfied star_border star_border star_border star_border star_border

    we usually ship in 1 day: 24h

    AVAILABILITY
    49,38 GBP

    with VAT

    we usually ship in 1 day: 24h

    MikroTik RBD53GR-5HacD2HnD&R11e-LTE6 | LTE Router | hAP ac3 LTE6 Kit, 5x RJ45 1000Mb/s, 1x USB, 1x microSIM
    MIKROTIK
    Product code: RBD53GR-5HACD2HND&R11E-LTE6
    sentiment_very_satisfied star_border star_border star_border star_border star_border

    we usually ship in 1 day: 24h

    AVAILABILITY
    151,76 GBP

    with VAT

    we usually ship in 1 day: 24h

    MikroTik Chateau LTE12 RBD53G-5HacD2HnD-TC&EG12-EA  | Router WiFi |  5x RJ45 1000Mb/s. LTE
    MIKROTIK
    Product code: RBD53G-5HACD2HND-TC&EG12-EA
    sentiment_very_satisfied star_border star_border star_border star_border star_border

    possible availability within 7 days

    AVAILABILITY
    live_help
    160,98 GBP

    with VAT

    possible availability within 7 days

    MikroTik Audience | WiFi Router | RBD25G-5HPacQD2HPnD, Tri Band, Mesh, 2x RJ45 1000Mb/s
    MIKROTIK
    Product code: RBD25G-5HPACQD2HPND
    sentiment_very_satisfied star_border star_border star_border star_border star_border

    we usually ship in 1 day: 24h

    AVAILABILITY
    123,56 GBP

    with VAT

    we usually ship in 1 day: 24h

    Choose a different country or region to shop in the language that suits you
    Our site uses cookies (so-called "cookies"). You can find more about these files, as well as about how we process your personal data, in our privacy policy.